Shear Buckling of Isotropic Panels – Post 3 – Beyond the Proportional Limit

April 16, 2016

You can read the first two posts in this series here:

Post 1, Post 2

When you calculate a buckling allowable that is beyond the material shear yield stress the allowable is unrealistic. For shear buckling this can be particularly problematic as the shear yield strength is not typically given in the common material data set so it can be difficult to know when it has been exceeded.

There is a method given in chapter 9 of (MIL-HNDBK-5H, 1998) for estimating the shear yield strength of a material:

Shear Yield Equation

Once you have the shear yield strength you have a rough idea of if your buckling allowable is in the plastic or elastic range of the material.

The simplest way to account for material plasticity is to limit the allowable to the shear yield strength. This is not very accurate, it can be either optimistic or conservative depending on the magnitude of the calculated elastic allowable, but it is ‘reasonable’ – we will do a comparison later in this post.

The better way to account for material non-linearity is to use the secant modulus, specifically the secant shear modulus Gs.

The secant shear modulus is given by the following expression:

Secant Shear Modulus

Where f is the applied stress and fsy is the shear yield stress and n is the Ramberg-Osgood Shape Factor.

To determine the shape factor for the shear stress/strain curve the following expression can be used as long as the traditional extensional shape factors are known.

shear shape factor

The plastic material correction factor for shear buckling is Gs/G

We construct a graph of that relates the linear shear buckling allowable to the Gs/G modified plastic buckling allowable. For a sample aluminum material that curve looks like this:

Plastic Shear Buckling Curve

Once you have constructed this curve you can plot the elastic buckling stress on the x-axis, project a line up to the curve and read the corrected plastic buckling stress from the Y axis:

Plastic Shear Buckling Curve 2

This curve can also be used to compare the simple approach of using the shear yield stress value as a simple cutoff value for the elastic stress:Plastic Shear Buckling Curve Comparison

For most aluminums the simple approach of using the Fsy value as a cut off value for shear buckling is appropriate for initial sizing.

As with all of the methods we use on a regular basis we have created a spreadsheet for full elasto-plastic shear buckling and you can down load it here

Plastic Shear Buckling Curve Spreadsheet

We also have a spreadsheet that calculates full range stress-strain curves and elasto-plastic buckling allowable curves for common buckling modes.

AA-SM-000-001 Aluminum Material Data

In the next post we will cover how to account for the presence of a hole in a shear panel.

AA SEZC Banner #6

To try our free Stress Analysis Engineering Spreadsheets click below


To try our Add-in for Microsoft Excel for Windows click below

XL-Viking 2

Have A Comment On This Article? Post It Here.

Comments are moderated and will not be published until approved. Your email address will be kept confidential. Please review our Comment Policy before posting your comment.


Microsoft Excel Spreadsheets

FREE ANALYSIS SPREADSHEETS 3 Over the last 10 years we have developed hundreds of spreadsheet tools to help us with our structural analysis work. We have made these available through the Abbott Aerospace web site and the XL Viking project. We have now brought them into the technical library. They have been updated, improved and the collection has been expanded to cover more analysis methods than ever before.

The XL-Viking Add-In for Excel

XL-Viking 2 We created the XL-Viking Excel add-in to satisfy our own need to make Excel a better engineering tool. XL-Viking shows your Excel Formula in a way that makes sense and brings essential new functionality to Microsoft Excel by providing an additional user interface and easy to use functions.

The Indispensable Tool For Engineers, Mathematicians, Scientists, Accountants and Teaching Professionals!


Technical Papers & Reports

This is our collection of public domain references. All of the material we make available has been placed in the public domain by the authors/owners. If you believe this is not the case and any of the library material is not in the public domain please let us know. If you have any reference material that you would like to see included in the library we would love to hear from you.

Market Analysis and Market Information

Our newest addition to the library is an on-going series of articles on the aircraft and aerospace market. These are part quantitative and part qualitative and introduce a new aspect to the competencies within Abbott Aerospace.